AsecretiveUSDrug

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, August 12, 2013

Government Should Bear the Burden of Showing Why You Can’t Exercise Your Right to Bear Arms

Posted on 12:59 AM by Unknown
OFF THE WIRE
By Ilya Shapiro
For anyone who has watched The Wire, it’s no surprise that Maryland (Baltimore, in particular) has one of the highest rates of violent crime in the country. In an alleged effort to address this persistent problem, the state requires an applicant for a license to carry a handgun to demonstrate “a good and substantial reason to wear, carry, or transport a handgun as a reasonable precaution against apprehended danger.”
Under this prove-it-to-use-it standard, Baltimore County resident Raymond Woollard, who had had a license to carry for six years (after a violent home invasion), was denied a license renewal because he could not document that he had been threatened recently. The fact that he had been attacked by his son-in-law seven years earlier, an event to which it took law enforcement two-and-a-half hours to respond, was insufficient to meet Maryland’s special-need requirement.
Woollard, along with the Second Amendment Foundation, thus brought suit challenging the law under the Supreme Court’s recent decisions in District of Columbia v. Heller (2008) and McDonald v. Chicago (2010). Although the district court ruled for Woollard, finding that Maryland’s restriction violated the Second Amendment, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit overturned the lower court and reinstated the law. The court purported to apply “intermediate scrutiny,” which allows a challenged statute to survive only if it is “substantially related to the achievement of an important governmental interest,” but in fact, hardly applied any scrutiny at all. The court’s analysis was both circular and contemptuous of Heller, finding that a regulation is “substantially related” to the valid government interest of curtailing criminal gun violence if it merely reduces the number of citizens lawfully carrying handguns, thus accepting the state’s implicit argument that the right to bear arms was itself the problem, one that should not be overcome without “a good and substantial” reason.
Cato has filed a brief supporting the plaintiffs’ request that the Supreme Court review the case and clarify that the Second Amendment protects more than the right to keep a gun in one’s home. The deferential approach that the Fourth Circuit took here mirrors the weakened scrutiny applied in the Second Circuit’s decision in Kachalsky v. Cacace, in which Cato also filed a brief. In Kachalsky, the court upheld a New York law requiring applicants for a carry license to show “proper cause.” Instead of requiring the state to demonstrate a concrete connection between the restriction and crime prevention, the court deferred to the political branches’ “discretionary judgment” on the issue.
However, other courts have expounded different doctrines since the Supreme Court ruled in Heller that the Second Amendment protects an individual right. For example, the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit demands that a restriction on Second Amendment rights satisfy a heightened level of scrutiny that requires “an extremely strong public-interest justification and a close fit between the government’s means and its end.” This confusion between lower courts lies at the very heart of the definition of Second Amendment rights outside of the home, and is in dire need of clarification.
As with all other constitutional rights, the political branches cannot limit the exercise of Second Amendment rights to those who can demonstrate some “special need.” Whatever standard may ultimately govern, this case provides an ideal opportunity for the Supreme Court to reaffirm what the district court said in this case about Woollard’s exercise of the constitutional right to armed self-defense: “The right’s existence is all the right he needs.”
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • (no title)
  • NEVEDA - Mass resignations hit Metro review board
    OFF THE WIRE Mass resignations hit Metro review board; chairman cites sheriff’s refusal to fire officer involved in shooting. Sheriff Doug ...
  • NORTH WILDWOOD - Disabled veteran kicked off boardwalk because of service dog..
    OFF THE WIRE Posted By Matt Alba - email   NORTH WILDWOOD - A disabled U.S. Army veteran, who served our country for 19 years, says he w...
  • NEVEDA - 5 members of Vegas police use-of-force panel quit..
    OFF THE WIRE The Associated Press LAS VEGAS — Several civilian mem...
  • California, Undercover Officer Provides Inside Look Into Local Gang
    OFF THE WIRE Source: 10news.com SANTEE, Calif. -- Authorities say a Santee-based gang, whose members include convicted felons with long rap ...
  • DISTRESS CALL:
    OFF THE WIRE DISTRESS CALL: To all of my Soldiers, family members or anyone that can help, I am seeking combat boots, new or used any type a...
  • CALIFORNIA - Espinoza's Leather
    OFF THE WIRE Espinoza's Leather Contact Information Phones (626) 307-5049 Work Address 8730 E Garvey Ave Rosemead, CA 91770 Website http...
  • Low Profile!
    OFF THE WIRE Profile! In 2009, a man, a former police officer, was moving from the state of ME to TX.  He made the profound mistake of drivi...
  • USA - 13NR25 - MRF News Release - Motorcycle Only Checkpoint 1 July, 2013
    OFF THE WIRE MRF E-MAIL NEWS Motorcycle Riders Foundation 236 Massachusetts Ave. NE | Suite 204 | Washington, DC 20002-4980 202-546-0983 (...
  • Ten Rules for Recording Cops and other Authority Figures (Citizen Journalism 101)
    OFF THE WIRE By Carlos Miller This is the first draft of the cover of my upcoming book, which is scheduled to be published next summer. For ...

Categories

  • about (1)
  • contact (1)
  • upcoming shows (1)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  September (217)
    • ▼  August (205)
      • Before You Sue ...
      • PIC OF THE DAY
      • Sons of Anarchy' spoilers: Ending has two opposing...
      • BABE OF THE DAY
      • Disinformation: How It Works UPDATE...
      • New Research Supports the Notion That There’s No S...
      • UTAH - Law enforcement preps for Labor Day
      • ARIZONA - Still no charges filed in Iron Brotherho...
      • AUSTRALIA - Treating tattooists like criminals wo...
      • SAN DIEGO, CA - Police cracking down on motorcycli...
      • EMILIO RIVIERA -Celebrity Interviews - Part 1 & 2 ...
      • The Sam Cro Radio Show, Exclusive interview with f...
      • NEW YORK - Appeals Court: Asking For Lawyer Doesn’...
      • U.S. Dominates Volume Of Government Requests For F...
      • USA - With cameras watching, your car isn't your c...
      • Protect your privacy from event data recorders
      • BABES OF THE DAY
      • USA - ACLU raises privacy concerns about police te...
      • How to serve a warrant: 1972 versus today, by Lt. ...
      • PIC OF THE DAY
      • California Begins Confiscating Legally-Purchased Guns
      • USA - FISA Court Ruled NSA Program Unconstitutiona...
      • BABE OF THE DAY
      • The Art of Being Seen On Your Motorcycle, Announce...
      • Sons of Anarchy Season Six Teaser Trailer Released...
      • ALL ABOUT THE BUTTS TUESDAY..
      • USA - Substitutionary Justice In A Free Society
      • Rusty Coones and Rodrigo Requejo Are Hell Raisers
      • Babe`s of the DAY..... This is 18 and older. Rest...
      • Knowledge
      • Knowledge - Do you strive for knowledge?
      • Babe`s of the DAY.....
      • Sample CPRA request letter
      • CA - Federal Investigation Tip-Off Didn't Obstruct...
      • Austraila - Push to deny permits for outlaw motorc...
      • USA - Bikers to counter Muslim march...
      • AUSTRAILA - Police could search without warrant..WTF
      • Boot Ride 2013 with Sons of Anarchy
      • CA - Investigations, Proceedings And SOA
      • USA - The who's who, How I Exposed an Undercove...
      • CALIFORNIA - Join the Boot Campaign Motorcycle Clu...
      • Drones find new fans in Middle East and Asia
      • USA - Obamacare is coming, and so are the con artists
      • Attorney General: Drug Sentences Need Reform, Too ...
      • New English Language Word
      • Seattle police to distribute Doritos at pot rally
      • USA - 'High' taxes
      • USA - Pentagon unveils measures to combat sexual a...
      • BABES OF THE DAY
      • CA - George Christie Going To Prison
      • USA - What’s at stake? A ban on your right to sel...
      • USA - Eric Holder: "widespread incarceration...is ...
      • Taxes, Regulations Drive Americans to Underground ...
      • Colorado - Whistle-Blowing Retired Marine Puts Hal...
      • NSA loophole allows warrantless search for US citi...
      • USA - Armed TSA teams now roam in public, conduct ...
      • Oregon Governor Signs Medical Cannabis Dispensary ...
      • See you LABOR DAY WEEK-END Locura Festival!!
      • USA - A secretive U.S. Drug Enforcement Administra...
      • CA - (Video) OC Deputy Detains Dr. For Filming Ar...
      • CA - The marijuana industry's latest 'it product':...
      • Illegal Traffic Stop in Oregon
      • Most Common Motorcycle Accidents (And How to Avoid...
      • It’s on: California state senate passes ammunition...
      • USA - DEA has doubled its asset seizures since 200...
      • BABE OF THE DAY
      • Here’s How Much You’ll Pay Not To Enroll In Obamacare
      • All about motorcycle insurance
      • NORTH WILDWOOD - Disabled veteran kicked off board...
      • Pls share.
      • Cato Makes Dick Durbin’s Enemies List
      • USA - Here Are 5 God-Given Rights That Democrats W...
      • NEW YORK - Stop-and-Frisk Practice Violated Rights...
      • Iranians Could Be Radicalizing Mexicans; Border Pa...
      • MASS - "POW/MIA Commemorative Chair"
      • NEW YORK - Federal Judge Rules Bloomberg's NYC 'St...
      • PIC OF THE DAY
      • USA - A secretive U.S. Drug Enforcement Administra...
      • Police Who Lie, Part 1: Canadian National Police B...
      • WARNING!!!! If you take photos with your cell phone
      • Anti-gun politicians claim we're headed for a gun ...
      • USA - The Who's Who -
      • All too often, other drivers cause motorcycle acci...
      • WASHINGTON DC - FBI allowed informants to commit 5...
      • USA - Why Have Police In America Turned Into Such ...
      • USA - Where Police Can & Can't Snoop Through Your ...
      • BABE OF THE DAY..
      • DISCLAIMER
      • Recently, we learned that the NSA's mass surveilla...
      • USA - Stop "Organizing for Action"--Take Your Own ...
      • CA - Governor Brown Signs "Bathroom Bill" Into Law
      • New York's stop-and-frisk trial comes to a close w...
      • CA - Michael Henry “Delano Mike” Pena
      • BABE OF THE DAY
      • Scientists Say Riding Makes You Smarter — But We K...
      • USA - Exploited by Your Tax Dollars...........
      • Government Should Bear the Burden of Showing Why Y...
      • NYPD Hammered for Targeting Minorities With Stop a...
      • http://www.blogtalkradio.com/bikersofamerica.rss
      • Bikers of America, The Phil and Bill Show Online R...
    • ►  July (78)
Powered by Blogger.