AsecretiveUSDrug

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, July 28, 2013

Salinas v. Texas

Posted on 12:59 AM by Unknown
OFF THE WIRE
By Tim Lynch
Today, the Supreme Court issued its ruling in Salinas v. Texas. Surprisingly, the Court did not answer the primary question court watchers were expecting, which was whether a prosecutor can deride a person’s reliance upon the right against self-incrimination when that person has not been arrested. The Court said it did not have to reach that question because the person here, Salinas, never really properly invoked his constitutional right against self incrimination.  And because he didn’t, there was nothing wrong with the prosecutor’s comments at his trial. This is a lousy ruling.
A bit more background. Everyone knows from TV shows, that once a person is arrested and the police start an interrogation, the Miranda warnings are given.  “You have the right to remain silent, right to a lawyer if you cannot afford one and anything you say can be used against you in court, etc”  The Supreme Court has also held, properly, that if anyone declines to take the witness stand during the trial, the prosecutor can’t attack that choice to the jury with comments like, “He could have taken the stand to tell us his side of the story, but he didn’t. That tells us quite a bit, doesn’t it?” The rationale against allowing that sort of “evidence” is that if one really has a right against self-incrimination, the government should not be permitted to attack it. The prosecutor must use other evidence to persuade the jury of guilt.
So, again, the government can’t offer negative comments on the choice not to testify and may not offer negative comments on a person’s choice to remain silent after an arrest. Salinas brought the question, what about silence before an arrest? Cato filed a brief saying prosecutors should also be barred from attacking pre-arrest silence.
Justice Alito announced today that the main question is again postponed for another day. The Court said Salinas simply remained silent and did not “formally” invoke any constititional right, so prosecutors could offer commentary to the jury. What’s most disturbing about the ruling is its discussion of “burdens.” The plurality put the onus on the individual, not the government. That is the profound error in the decision. As the dissenters noted, in the circumstances of the case, it was evident what Salinas was doing. Unfortunately, the Supreme Court has complicated the law for persons who are the most vulnerable–persons who lack education, persons who do not speak English very well, persons who may suffer from mental problems, and persons who may be under the influence of alcohol. This is a bad day for the Bill of Rights.

Related Content




Public More Wary of NSA Surveillance Than Pundits Claim

Emily McClintock Ekins
A closer look at the poll results on Americans’ opinion on NSA surveillance.

Federal Judge to Kentucky Bureaucrats: Stop Prohibiting Free Competition

Ilya Shapiro
Federal judge strikes down Kentucky’s absurd licensing laws for moving companies.

Richard Epstein’s Ricochet Post on the NSA

Tim Lynch
A closer look at the government agencies Richard Epstein claims “to have performed well” in response to terrorism.

Cato Brief Gains National Acclaim

Ilya Shapiro
National Law Journal calls our filing in next term’s big treaty power case its “brief of the week.”
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • California, Undercover Officer Provides Inside Look Into Local Gang
    OFF THE WIRE Source: 10news.com SANTEE, Calif. -- Authorities say a Santee-based gang, whose members include convicted felons with long rap ...
  • (no title)
  • USA - Expunction Orders Kept Out of Federal Court
    OFF THE WIRE By CAMERON LANGFORD      (CN) - A law that allows the U.S. government to assert federal jurisdiction over claims against it i...
  • ARIZONA - Bikers rousted at northern Ariz. motorcycle rally after shooting sue police
    OFF THE WIRE http://www.therepublic.com/ view/story/ 89fe19ca330149208b656a56b6c912 a5/AZ--Motorcycle-Rally- Lawsuit    Bikers rousted at no...
  • SAM CRO RADIO SHOW - JOIN US WED NITE AS WE INTERVIEW, FEATURED MAYAN SEASON 4, EDDY "HOLLYWOOD" CARDENAS
    OFF THE WIRE   JOIN US WED NITE AS WE INTERVIEW, FEATURED MAYAN SEASON 4, EDDY "HOLLYWOOD" CARDENAS  AND REMEMBER, IF YOU CAN’T TU...
  • CA - Should Cops Be Allowed to Profile Bikers?
    OFF THE WIRE Members of a motorcycle club called the "Sons of Hell" claim in a federal lawsuit that they were treated unfairly by...
  • USA - State by State Look at Motorcycle and Bicycle Helmet Use Laws..
    OFF THE WIRE The history of motorcycle helmet laws in the United States is characterized by change. In 1967, to increase motorcycle helm...
  • NORTH WILDWOOD - Disabled veteran kicked off boardwalk because of service dog..
    OFF THE WIRE Posted By Matt Alba - email   NORTH WILDWOOD - A disabled U.S. Army veteran, who served our country for 19 years, says he w...
  • USA - The NSA Admits It Analyzes More People's Data Than Previously Revealed
    OFF THE WIRE Philip Bump   As an aside during testimony on Capitol Hill today, a National Security Agency representative rather casually ...
  • AUSTRALIA - Police put bikies on notice
    OFF THE WIRE IT has taken more than four years, but Gold Coast police have finally moved to tackle the city's outlaw bikie gangs, promi...

Categories

  • about (1)
  • contact (1)
  • upcoming shows (1)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  September (217)
    • ►  August (205)
    • ▼  July (78)
      • FLORIDA - RIDE 4 HOPE
      • Come join me at KNOXVILLE'S FINEST PRESENT: WOUNDE...
      • USA - 13NR25 - MRF News Release - Motorcycle Only ...
      • DELAWARE - DUI check location invalid
      • BABES OF THE DAY
      • PIC OFF THE DAY
      • BABE OF THE DAY
      • RFID Chip Now Being Issued In Hanna, Wyoming As Pa...
      • How Gov & Marijuana Industry Lobbies Fight Against...
      • AUSTRALIA - Police put bikies on notice
      • BABES OF THE DAY
      • USA - Harley-Davidson drops the Road Glide, analys...
      • Montana - TO serve and deflect
      • Glendale HD Summer Party
      • 7eye by Panoptx
      • BABE`s OF THE DAY
      • USA - State photo-ID databases become troves for p...
      • USA - Veterans Kept as Guinea Pigs to Get Some Relief
      • MINNESOTA - Stillwater Police will Crack Down on M...
      • Arizona - No charges yet in Iron Brotherhood crimi...
      • New York - Informant planting drugs caught on video
      • Salinas v. Texas
      • What makes a police officer powerless? When citize...
      • The Department of Homeland Security says it is ill...
      • Riverside, California to vote on backing out of re...
      • AUSTRALIA - Tax Office specialists claw back $1.7m...
      • Obama & Department of Homeland Security Planned To...
      • Cop Fired for Speaking Out Against Ticket and Arre...
      • About Bikers of America, " THE PHIL & BIL SHOW " ...
      • Contact Us
      • Five Tips for Spotting an Undercover Cop.......
      • USA - Coming down the track like a freight train.
      • PIC OF THE DAY
      • NCOM BIKER NEWSBYTES
      • Defense and Law Enforcement in an Anarchist Society
      • Secrets Police Don't Want You To Know
      • FROM 4409: How to fight a DISORDERLY CONDUCT Charge
      • PIC OF THE DAY
      • CA - Fresno police target behavior risky to motorc...
      • CA - Bakersfield Police MC unit disbanding
      • The world's top 5 military spenders
      • Rep. Kelly Applauds Committee Approval of Funding ...
      • A.B.A.T.E. of South Dakota collecting data on law ...
      • PIC OF THE DAY.. LEXA
      • US - States Where Owning a Silencer Is Legal........
      • Babes of the Day
      • No warrant needed?
      • Who Polices The Police? Eyewitnesses Document Misc...
      • USA - While Your Phone Calls Are Tracked & Stored ...
      • Lane Splitting Guidelines
      • BE SOME DRUNK ASS FANS !
      • Class Claims DC Cops Target Black Motorcyclists
      • CA. - Don't Call Sheriff for Help, LA Family Says
      • USA - Air Force Unveils Spirit: The 7th Largest Su...
      • USA - SHOCK: Border Patrol Deporting Illegal Alien...
      • North Carolina Expands Concealed Carry Permits
      • IRS needs to be audited! Read this! $46 million se...
      • BABE OF THE WEEK - Kaity aka "Daft Kat"
      • ARIZONA - Bikers rousted at northern Ariz. motorcy...
      • AUSTRALIA - Melbourne court rules random police ...
      • BABE OF THE DAY
      • Study Finds Cannabis Stimulates Brain Growth
      • USA - Driving Somewhere? There's A Government Reco...
      • FLORIDA - Tampa Police Rev Up Motorcycle Enforcement
      • Coast to Coast Legislative Report for July 2013
      • USA - 627:4 Physical Force in Defense of a Person.
      • USA - The NSA Admits It Analyzes More People's Dat...
      • USA - Rise of the Warrior Cop
      • ARIZONA - Police Biker Clubs Draw Scrutiny in Wake...
      • COLORADO - Motorcyclist Uses Gun to Ward off Robbers
      • Monsanto Video Revolt July 24, 2013 ~ Say NO To GM...
      • SO CAL - HIN Spocom 2 PART 2
      • Low Profile!
      • WASHINGTON - Spokane police officer suspended for ...
      • Don't Cry For Me .... Detroit
      • ARIZONA - Stubbs Sues GIITEM
      • Too Loud Laws - Noise Laws, around the USA
      • SO, CAL - HIN/SPOCOM, This was last Saturday.
Powered by Blogger.